Have you shaved with a straight razor from Vintage Straight Razor? How was it?
If you have purchased a razor from VSR and have shaved with it, please share your experience here. (If you haven't shaved with it yet, please sit this one out.)
I've been on the fence about trying one for a while but I've been waiting to hear what popular opinion has to say. Instead of sifting through the comments on all of VSR's past deals and trying to keep track of duplicate reviews posted in multiple threads, I'd like to do some consolidation and have people post their experiences here.
by
rustybender
asked 7 months ago
Here's some guidelines I think would be helpful in making this a valuable thread:
Make sure you mention which model(s) you have.
Please be detailed. don't just say you love it; tell us what you love about it. Same goes if you hate it.
Let us know how experienced you are with using a straight razor.
Keep it focused on the product. Let talk about razors, not service.
And one final (big) request, please keep personal attacks to a minimum. If someone posts a review of their shaving experience, they should not have to write countless replies defending it just because you have a differnt opinion of the product. People are going to have different experiences and I want to hear about all of them. (if you don't like a review, try down-voting instead)
I've had a safety razor on my wishlist for a year or two now and just haven't taken the time to pick on up. I'm interested in straight razors too, but I really don't want to take the time to upkeep the blade (While I find it intriguing, and I love sharpening my knives - I just don't have the time).
I'm pretty surpised that nobody has posted there experience. Based on the arguing that takes place in the item comments, I assumed there were dozens of wooters with these razors.
@atomicorange: You should at least give a safety razor a try. They are very easy to use, and they give a great shave. Depending on the day, I either use a straight or a safety.
A quality straight isn't much work to maintain. My Dovo came shave ready when I bought it (4-5 months ago) and I haven't needed to sharpen it yet. 20-30 strokes on a strop before I shave is the only maintenance I've done on it.
Are you kidding me? Every time this joker has one of these deals up, people post numerous links to reviews. The comments for the latest "deal" (11-12-11) has a comment directly above yours with no less than SIX links for exactly what you requested. Can you not read?
Maybe wooters aren't posting their experiences either because so few of them actually bought said deal thanks to warnings from people who know better, or they are just too embarrassed to admit that they, against all warnings, bought the deal and realized when they tried shaving that they had purchased useless junk.
You own a Dovo. You know how a good quality razor should perform. Feel free to buy one of these "deals" yourself and post what you find. If you do, I'll save myself the trouble later and just say "I told you so" right now.
They "hone" their razors with a frickin' ELECTRIC KNIFE SHARPENER, FFS! Do you truly want to give this guy the benefit of a doubt?
I bought 2 of this deal
I left a remark there.
Essentially the razor I got was a basic straight razor, hone and polish were good i have shave with it three times now.
Can you buy a better razor sure, for these prices probably not.
Can you get a better shave from a more expensive razor yeah, my girlfriend just bought me a dovo 5/8 that shaves slightly better but she spent much more around $260.00.(she didn't quite get that I wanted to shave with a straight razor on occasion not every time.)
I bought these more as a novelty they look nice on the counter and make a nice show piece look as good as my new dovo for a lot less.
I didn't have any problems with the blade or the shave. It was the same sensation as getting it done by the barber just took me a hell of a lot longer.
These blades are like everything else you get what you pay for. If I was going to shave 3+ times a week with it I would get something that cost more and had a better rep.(like the Dovo) For the occasional shave or a nice show piece the price is great.
Honestly I do my daily shaving with an expensive electric, and I am by no means a straight razor expert. I have had by barber doing it two to three times a year for the last 10 years, and I shaved three times with the razor linked above, and twice with my new dovo.
These are a step above the "knife razors or show only razors" but are less than a $200 + blade.
And I have stated in my review posted in the above link. I am going to leave most of my straight razor shaving to my barber.
But for $50, these worked fine for what they are.
Most of the reviews are on sites that cater to people that are too into shaving.
Take the reviews linked to with a grain of salt like all ways.
Most of these people like to think of them selves as experts and connoisseurs, some may be, some aren't.
I will admit I am not.
But I used to product and it worked out fine for me.
Think of the most of the reviews in this light.
If you park a new Lamborghini next to a new Corvette, most car experts will tear the Corvette apart in comparison without noting that the Corvette costs less than half of the price of the Lamborghini.
But in the end they both are just cars that cost too much and are too specialized for most people or purposes.
@comma: Calm down. The point of this thread was to offer some consolidation. It is a lot easier to read one thread full of reviews than to hunt through a dozen different threads.
I've read all the comments in all the threads. My issue is there are so many comments spread out across so many threads that without taking notes it is hard to tell if there are lots and lots of bad reviews, or just the same 3 or 4 people re-posting the same bad experiences over and over.
The negative reviews stand out in my mind but if you go back through those threads, there are some people who say the razor is nice. However, most of the positive reviews I can recall were essentially "It looks nice and sharp, now I just need to get up the nerve to try it." Since I'm not interested in buying a pocket knife, those reviews are worthless.
I thought it would be interesting to see if anyone with experience was actually using the razor on a regular basis. So far it doesn't seem that way.
@regionalagent: You would be surprised how diverse the straight shaving community is. We are not all snobs.
There is a pretty large segment of straight shavers who enjoy looking for hidden gems among all the cheap new razors being sold. They are interested in cheap quality shaves, not $300 works of art.
They aren't interested in comparing Corvettes to Lamborghinis. They are looking for Camrys to compare Civics.
I guess my point is don't make the mistake of discounting the review of an experienced shaver as being overly picky. As long as they shave nice, a lot of shaving connoisseurs would have no problem with recommending Luke's razors and would consider them a prize.
I wouldn't call what I did with this razor "shaving." I did attempt to remove my whiskers, but in shipped "shave ready" condition it failed to do that, so I rehoned it myself and managed to do a single pass of my cheek, cutting approximately 1/5 of the hairs and pulling something awful. This was my first experience with a straight razor so I didn't exactly know what to expect. I have since gotten a real straight razor from another vendor (vintage refurb and new strop for $48) which shaves great. The good news: Luke has a great return policy and offers excellent customer service. On the other hand, I ordered it because I wanted a razor, not because I wanted my money back.
@rustybender: The point wasn't to attack the straight razor community. The point was to show that most of the reviews point to something that costs two to ten times more than the razors being offered by this vendor.
The analogy between the cars was an attempt to point this out so it is not comparing a Camry to a Civic as the cost between the two is competitive $15,000-30,000 for each dependent on options etc. Where as a new corvette runs between $50,000-112,000 and a new Lamborghini Aventador starts at around $385,000.
So comparing a new razor $30-$70.00 dollar kit form this vendor to to a $99-$300+ razor is what that was attempting to show. Several of the reviews do tell you how to find a nice used razor on a budget, but the overwhelming majority point you to buy a Dovo or similar.
I posted a review the last time these were offered. I'd copy-paste it if I could find it, but I'll try ti recall the short version.
Stropped it up, it cut smoothly, the pivot is a little tight, and the blade is large (almost 7/8" compared to my other 2 straights that are 1/2" and 5/8"). With the size of the blade, cheeks and neck are easy, but it is a little big to get around the chin/mouth/nose.
Hello Group! @rustybender thank you for posting this question. I will encourage people that ordered to post as well.
I just uploaded a quick video on a couple of the blades in action. Here is the link.
http://www.vintagestraightrazor.com/product/VSR-VIDEO
I made this video about 10 days ago and being Movember I am not shaving my head or face in it however I do show the quality that should be expected for shaving from one of our razors when they arrive.
The 2nd half of the video has a better view of the blades cutting a ton of hair.
Regards,
Luke
I bought the GB Buckingham Black Pakka Wood Razor.
I had experience with straight edge razors that use disposable razors.
How did the shave go? Well it wasn't shave ready like advertized, so I had an experienced friend hone and strop the blade until he thought it was sharp enough. The blade itself had a frown and was slightly warped. When I tried to shave I got one pass out of it where it cut decently, but then it started a nasty pull and tug on my beard. I had to resharpen it to go for another pass but the same thing happened. I have since moved back to the disposable straight razors and have had no problems shaving.
My overall opinion? Do not buy. If you really must buy from VSR, purchase the DOVO, but you can find it for much cheaper elsewhere (Amazon, other straight razor vendors, etc.). The lifetime honing is also not worth it, you have to pay to ship it to him for sharpening, and obviously they don't know how to sharpen as mine couldn't even cut my finger when I got it.
I purchased their camel bone razor deal back in October. The razor I got was not shave ready, did a lot of pulling and left my face red from irritation. The steel they are made from is not high carbon steel. The razor had some pits on the side of the blade. On top of that VSR took the time to go and remove the stamp on the side of the blade that said GB Buckingham and Sons.
The links that have been posted are from people who have bought razors from them.
On straightrazorplace Luke had an account on there and posted on a thread. At one point he had gotten himself banned and he had deleted his posts on the website. If he stood behind his product you'd think he would not delete his comments.
@buddhaj: I did not delete my comments. The forum did. If you contact us on the sites customer support we will be happy to help you.
Regards,
Luke
16 Answers answer
Sort By: