questionswho do you think was the greatest beatle?

vote-for14vote-against
vote-for9vote-against

The whole was SO much better than the parts.

vote-for3vote-against

@morriea: You think?
My Sweet Lord- George
Imagine- John
Band on the Run- Paul
Ringo-???

vote-for5vote-against

John was the greatest Beatle, although he needed Paul (and the others to some degree) to reign him in and produce the perfect signature Beatles sound. Like a lot of the best bands, they played to each others strengths and filled in each others' weaknesses.

vote-for2vote-against

My choice would be Volks Wagen. ;->

vote-for3vote-against

I always loved John & his solo work. Then as I got older I grew to have a huge appreciation for George. I saw Paul at the Orange Bowl somewhere between 1989-1990, had 10th row tix and thought he was amazing. Never saw Ringo and I've never followed his solo work. But as a whole, they were awesome.
They had come and gone as a group before I was born but once I was introduced, they have always been a favorite of mine.

vote-for2vote-against

I assumed from your question that one of them had died. Usually that's when people ask questions like this.

Personally I liked the group better than any of them as individuals, like Morriea said.

vote-for2vote-against

I'll know when there is only one left. That one, will be the greatest.