questionstimeshares - what makes them a good deal? easy…

vote-for34vote-against +34 -0

by jwildman16
asked 4 months ago

vote-for6vote-against

The only experience I have is thinking the same as you are now and researching and reading. Decided they are not a good deal. By the time you buy it, pay the annual fees and taxes, pay a fee to change with someone else, at least in my experience it was not worth it. I would rather go when/where I want and try to find reasonable accomodations.

vote-for8vote-against

My brother was given a timeshare for free. They like it, but that's comparing the annual fees to the equivalent expenses. If you had to add on the cost to buy the thing in the first place, I don't think it would make much financial sense for anyone.

That said, if you want a timeshare, buy one on the secondary market. The mark-ups on new sales are ridiculous.

vote-for5vote-against

I've always maintained that if timeshares were such a great deal, they wouldn't be given away for free so often

vote-for2vote-against

What about when two couples split the cost? Assume I can fully rely on them.

vote-for8vote-against

right now is a terrible time to own a timeshare. The market is over-saturated and people who own them LITERALLY can't even give them away for free. More & more people are jsut walking away from them, which means the people who keep paying their annual fees get charged more and more, since there are fewer people to pay for the upkeep of the hotel/resort.

read up about them at clarkhoward.com

I recall going to a sales presentation about 3 years ago for a new one being built, and the first sale price we were pushed was $45,000. A half hour later they were down to $8,000 and offering 2 weeks per year instead of 1 week at that price. Final offer was to buy a "used" timeshare at this resort from some other sucker who no longer wanted theirs, for $5,000.

vote-for8vote-against

quote:
"The time share business is spiraling into a state of near collapse. Developers and marketers are more desperate to unload time shares and stave off bankruptcy than Clark can ever recall.

For a brief spell, time shares almost gained respectability thanks to the interest of Hilton, Marriott, Wyndham and others in their development and sale.

But buying a time share is not an investment, it is an obligation. The typical time share loses 80% of its value the moment you buy it.

The Wall Street Journal reports that the big hoteliers themselves can't get money to fund time-share operations.

The only way to even consider buying a time share is to get one secondhand at a deep discount from a private owner. But even then, if the operator of the time share is insolvent, you'll likely have problems with maintenance of amenities like pools or tennis courts. "

vote-for4vote-against

I love my time share but the key is to buy resale and be flexible.

vote-for4vote-against

I've had a time share for probably 20 years. I love it. I've used it often for US vacations. For $90-100, I can get a 2 bedroom, 2 bath condo with a full kitchen. Most often, I've traded for Las Vegas or Orlando. I've also done Malibu and Montana. When I haven't been able to get away, I've rented mine to pay for the yearly maintenance.

Edit: As to buying one now? I don't know if it would make sense although, there may be some good buys in resales.

vote-for2vote-against

lots of "good buys" are out there right now, just look at ebay! ($1)
http://www.ebay.com/itm/VILLAS-POLO-TOWERS-CASINO-GOLF-LAS-VEGAS-NEVADA-TIMESHARE-/160724802964?pt=Timeshares&hash=item256bf1dd94
the problem is the company may go bankrupt tomorrow and the fees can go up at any time.

vote-for1vote-against

My BFF and I bought one in Vegas at Polo Towers. It's a great location and we got a good deal on it but we still regret it. What we really regret is that, when he declared bankruptcy a few years ago we switched it to my name to protect it from the bankruptcy, when in retrospect we should have put it in his name and used the bankruptcy to get rid of it. It's almost paid off so we will soon have only maintenance fees, which won't be too bad. We're hoping to be able to sublet it for enough to cover the maintenance fees on years we don't use it. I am surprised there aren't more people just sub-letting these things as they are really quite nice, and our annual maintenance fees are less than a week at a nice hotel, plus it sleeps four and has a full kitchen. I just don't like Vegas much. I wish we'd bought someplace in CA that has a better climate. Anybody with a CA timeshare interested in a trade?