questionsshould we drop the leap year thing already?

vote-for-11vote-against +3 -14

by jgribb1
asked 4 months ago

vote-for12vote-against

I think you'll have to clarify the question.

If you're suggesting we stop "celebrating" Leap Year, you'd better come up with another way to account for the fact that the earth doesn't travel around the sun in exactly 365 days...

vote-for-3vote-against

have you heard about the guys that have created a callendar where every year your birthday will be on the same day of the week? they have 30 days in all but 2 or 3 months and have completely elimanted the need for leap day. i think the year has 364 days. also since seasons aren't exact, why do we need january to always be winter, etc?
but as for your question: it will never happen because what about all those people with birthdays or other occasions...

vote-for7vote-against

You realize that leap year has to do with the orbit of the sun, not making it a pain for people. We could switch to the Jewish calendar which has more natural ways of dealing with variations in celestial movement, but I'm pretty sure the red states would object...

It's every 4 years and gives people a reason to ask questions like this ;)

vote-for6vote-against

I do not want to denigrate the questioner, but what is wrong with our education system that people don't understand such fundamental issues? Anyone mature enough to be typing on a computer should know the reason for a leap year, and if you don't then you have been short changed in your education. I am willing to bet that only people taught in American public schools have this kind of deficiency of understanding.

vote-for3vote-against

Well, we could go back to the old method of having an extra month every seven(?) years, instead of an extra day every four years (with an exception every hundred years, and then an exception to the exception every 400 years).

We could change the number of days in a week, or weeks in a year, or even hours in a day, but none of these really fixes the problem completely and all are even more arbitrary than what we do now.

All in all, I'd say tossing in an extra day every few years is about as sensible a way as can be done.

vote-for3vote-against

@nortonsark: I don't want to denigrate myself, but I had to Google that term to find out what it meant.

@baqui63: If we have one day every four years how does 7 make a full month? Math seems a bit off IMO.

vote-for4vote-against

if we do, can we at least trade to get Pluto back? you know, drop that confusing and outdated leap year thing and bring hip Pluto back into the super circle of planetary friends?

vote-for4vote-against

@w00tgurl: It really is wrong what they did to Pluto. Disowning him like that.

Who has that kind of power anyways? What man actually has the power to unmake a planet? Did we elect him?

vote-for3vote-against

@drchops: the folk tales say it was Kim Jong-il, the same superhuman who invented the leap year as part of his diabolical plan to create world chaos and planetary resentment. One day the Plutonians will make us pay...

vote-for3vote-against

@captainsuperdawg:

I believe months were each 28 days as well, though I will freely acknowledge that it has been years since I looked into this and I did not do so before answering above.

vote-for3vote-against

I already only get a birthday only once every 4 years. Please don't take that away from me.

vote-for3vote-against

Leap years are not a gimmick like daylight savings time. They are a necessary correction to an imperfect calendar.

The calendar is based on the earth's orbit of the sun. Every year on a given day, the earth's position in its orbit will be very close to the same place on that same day year after year.

That is because 1 year = 1 orbit. Almost.

I say almost because the orbit takes approximately 365.25 days. Because the calendar year only has 365 days, the calendar becomes out of sync (by 6 hours each year) with the earth's true position in its orbit.
After 4 years, the earth's position would be a full day behind what the calendar reads.

The calender would essentially be acting like a clock that is running fast. And what do you do with a clock that runs fast? You adjust it.

The only difference is with a clock, you typically move the hands back so you are essentially repeating some minutes. With the calendar, we add a new day instead of repeating a day.

vote-for0vote-against

who let the kids in the group home on the interweb again?